October 1, 2000
The Sunday Times
"He Shoots He Scores"
By John Peters

100100_Sunday_Times_small.jpg (4205 bytes)
In the wars: Ray Winstone and Dougray Scott in To the Green Fields Beyond. Photograph: Mark Ellidge

In To the Green Fields Beyond (Donmar Warehouse), too, time is on hold. This is Nick Whitby's new play, for which Sam Mendes postponed his planned production of Twelfth Night, and the decision was worth it. This is a play of a quiet, brooding English apocalypse, but no less momentous for that. The setting is a wood in France in early 1918. A seven-man British tank crew, including an Irishman (Finbar Lynch), a Sikh (Nitin Ganatra), a West Indian (Danny Sapani) and a Scottish officer (Dougray Scott), stuck two miles behind the lines,
their tank camouflaged, are debating whether to break out. Observe the men of Britain about to march, or not, to almost certain death.

Whitby's writing combines the qualities of the ritual and the thriller. An American journalist (Paul Venables) turns up, looking for some defining image of the war that he could present to his readers at home, some of whom, he admits awkwardly, are of German descent. Instantly, suspicion begins to thicken as to what he is really after. One man, Cossum (Adrian Scarborough), has recruited a Belgian prostitute (Johanna Lonsky), a self-contained, quizzical middle-aged woman, to service the crew, some of whom are in a state of appalling sexual ignorance.

These men are in the kind of timeless no man's land you find yourself in before terrible decisions: this is why such decisions feel as if they made themselves, without you, out of time. "We are from a different time," one man says, and you feel as if you were in the presence of both history and mythology. "This is a holy place," somebody says, meaning, I think, that it is a privileged spot where prayers are both offered and received. Perhaps this is the last war. Perhaps a better world begins here. The play is heavy with the ironies of history.

The text is a bit of a problem. Whitby has clearly immersed himself in the period, and his writing is rich in obsolete technical terms, rhyming slang and the jokey abbreviations of long coexistence. This gives you a sense of immediacy, but it can also get in the way; the printed text, which I got hold of afterwards, has three pages of glossary.

Cossum quotes from the Bible; the Sikh and the West Indian read from a copy of Blake; one man has heard of Einstein (he calls him Bert One-stone) and his frightening theory; and the Scottish officer, a schoolteacher in civilian life, drops classical allusions. At first this feels self-conscious, as if Whitby were presenting his intellectual credentials, but gradually you realise that he is creating a realistic but poetic mythology where men are alone, abandoned and must create their own consolations.

Mendes's direction balances the great metaphor of Whitby's vision against the muddy realities of war with masterful confidence. In a shared, black doom, every character carries a private burden, and the performance has the angularities, the power and the moving interior silences of great music

Copyright 2000 Times Newspapers Ltd.